Showing posts with label battle record. Show all posts
Showing posts with label battle record. Show all posts

Thursday, 5 November 2026

Battle Record - Warhammer 40k Space Marines Vs Orks 05/11/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing MESBG... yes I know we were back on 40k and that's what it says above but Liam wanted to finish off the Goblin Town Vs Dwarves game we started weeks prior. If I'm honest I'd already moved on from it and thought it was somewhat of a pointless exercise. Losing priority and getting the Goblin King speed-bumped by lone Dwarves on the wrong side of the board as the precious heirloom escaped into the far left top corner did not improve my attitude to the game, especially when Ben and Otty were cracking on with the next game of 40k.


Ultimately I got broken, but it was a 25% game for it to end and this was as close as I got to recapturing the treasure. Thankfully a lot of goblins ran away which speeded up the inevitable loss. I felt a bit bad, because my mind wasn't in it. But I'd come expecting 40k and this felt like we'd already given up on it.


But no, we eventually joined in. Ben had used his Gorkamorka boards and terrain as they fit the footprints a bit better. Now I think the terrain pieces are a much better fit for the footprints. But I did prefer the greater height difference in the last layout. That said if it has dense terrain on it it's obscuring regardless. It just looks a bit odd to not have taller terrain pieces.


Da jump - again the ruling caused all sorts of arguments and hoping we would just consult the rulebook failed to bring about the calm solution I'd hoped to adopt for future games.


But after initial issues we cracked on. The game flowed a bit easier and despite the increased tension in this game I think we all began to enjoy it from a tactical and visual way.


I think there's still too many dice and the discrepancies in stat lines widen that gap. MESBG  has plenty of units hitting and wounding on 5s but here there are much more hitting and wounding on 3's with lots more models and attacks. 


The dakka-rig became even more of a threat and was the prime target for stopping the Orks. The Painboy too, bringing back Boyz like they'd never been killed seemed equally advantageous. Although they would be swiftly despatched in the very next turn.


I just don't know what it is about this game that causes so much frustration. Ben and I get to rationalise it in the car journey home, but poor Liam has to keep his own thoughts and it's not good staying up for hours afterward at home looking at rules online to get an understanding of how to play.


I genuinely think there are improvements in the new rulebook. But also there are some blatant ambiguities it would have been so easy to make clearer. It just feels like there needs an editor that consistently applies naming conventions rather than mix and match terms that seem familiar but sometimes are interposed. It's got to a point where I'm reading up on how foreign language versions are defining a rule and how that is translated back into English. Ultimately, we're enjoying the game, its not without issue and it's still not as much fun but we've not given up yet and it's so good to see these armies being used.


Tuesday, 3 November 2026

Battle Record - Warhammer 40k Space Marines Vs Orks 03/11/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing Warhammer 40k 11th Edition! Yes indeed, 40kaddict is playing 40k!


First up I'd taken the original Warhammer 40k terrain area footprints and recoloured them red to work on my Red Planet Realm of Battle board...


And then we go and create this madness! to be fair, the RoB board has inbuilt hills that are somewhat incompatible with the area footprints. Now although the actual terrain is something of mixed bag of trees, industrial elements and even Adeptus Titanicus ruins I do think the actual board looks decent. The actual LoS blocking terrain is there even if the unmatched colours and pieces are somewhat incongruous.


That said, setting it up was an exercise in madness. The measurements for how you place all the footprints are particularly fussy and the process of starting a game, by having to use the app was a real pain. There's a huge swing to competitive play here which seems opposite to GWs market of young beginners. This is far too complex, even for us players who've had year's of play and experience. Anyway we cracked on, I think Otty and Ben got first turn with the Orks.


And 'da jumped' into our backfield. Now, this may have been the first rules mistake. We can't tell if this sort of redeployment/strategic reserve/ingress/deep strike move is possible in turn one. There are all those keywords, rules and which take priority and which are applicable when specific wording is used while other wording is absent. Even web searches seemed inconclusive, with results sometimes featuring 10th edition rules.


The Dakka-rig strode forth and targeted the Intercessors, which were just in range. Liam was absent so I didn't think to use Armour of Contempt and half of the squad was wiped out. That failure to use the stratagem would haunt me for the remainder of the game. 


As well as the appalling saving throw... 🎲🎲🎲🎲


I'm not really sure what else happened in the game.


Clearly the Eradicators got wiped out but I think we were holding the central objective.


But even changing our dice wasn't enough. 🎲🎲🎲


Neither was whoever was rolling the dice 🎲🎲🎲🎲🎲


We carried on but we started to notice even more issues with the Space Marines


We'd been using the datacards - a totally handy way to keep track of your units, stats and special rules. It felt similar to Star War Legion having them alongside our front edge of the board.


But it would transpire that they are completely out of date and either the wrong edition or the codex itself has utterly replaced whatever was on the card. Obviously we've had the increase in Strength/Toughness [I forget which] and that isn.t on the cards.


So we'd refer back to the codex and discover that their special abilities and rules were wildly different too. Alongside many of the other rules, subtle changes to game play but use of the same rule names meant the rules debates were many and often fractious. Terrain in particular became a convoluted argument over what it hidden and is it true line-of-sight or an abstract...


Despite the smiles this was not what I would describe as a 'fun' game. That's not to say we couldn't have fun playing it, we definitely enjoyed it more than our previous 10th edition attempts. We were tolerant of the armies special rules, which was what seemed the issue last time. But it was the game mechanics  themselves that tripped us up here. Thankfully, we were not put off. We still want to play and hopefully with more experience it will be easier and less of a debate. What we need to do is stop assuming we know the rules and instead consult them. Follow them step-by-step each time. And learn 11th like new, rather than bring the baggage of previous editions - which seems to be clouding the gameplay. 



Thursday, 3 September 2026

Battle Record - Middle Earth - Army of the Dead Vs Sharku and Wargs #MESBG 03/09/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing MESBG again. We have a midweek MESBG event at Warhammer World again and both Ben and I had thought to take Scott's Army of the Dead, with Aragorn. But I had limited experience of it so this was a practice to try and understand how it plays against Otty's list of Sharku, a load of Warg riders and a Shamen with Wargs.


I've used the ghosts before, I know they're really fast, tough, cause terror and pretty much kill anything on a 4+. Throw in Aragorn and his free Might per turn and I'm just not used to having all those tools at my disposal.


So by the second turn I chose not to have priority, convinced Terror would stunt Otty's cavalry charge, except it didn't. Liam started to give me advice at this stage but I think I'd already caused the damage with about 4 ghosts dead for good!


I started to win a few duels, but all my wound rolls were just 1 or 2. I just couldn't seem to kill anything and it all seemed a little depressing. Or at least 'not fun'.


Because I knew the dice were disproportionately impacting the game and aside from my inexperience with them it felt like if I did know what I was doing they just wouldn't be fun for who I was up against.


With the mission to capture objectives and my army down to just a few ghosts left I sadly came to the conclusion I'd have had more fun with my Goblins. I doubt I'd have won, but I'd have enjoyed myself a lot more.


It was a shame as I wanted to take them for Scott, but I know he would have told me first and foremost have fun.


But I will not take the Scribe this time for more Goblins and see what that does to my state of play.



Thursday, 6 August 2026

Battle Record - Middle Earth - Beyond The Deeping Wall #MESBG 06/08/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing MESBG again. We're playing the next mission Beyond the Deeping Wall where the 'Elves' try to hold back the orcs having broken through the breach. And I finally got to take Tyler to the Shed of the Year to take part. Hilariously his first dice roll was a 1!


I can't remember many details but I think we had to get out of the 'water' which meant our movement range was halved. And this was our initial wrong set up with all the Orcs through the wall.


I think there might have been a limit to how many could breach it per turn.


So it didn't take long before we were pinned in the breach.


Getting out was almost impossible and the water meant even if you won you couldn't get very far.


Meanwhile the Rohan army was desperately trying to get Legolas onto the wall so he could 'slide down the stairs'.


It was just a bun fight with very little progress beyond the wall.


I don't think we won this one either, but it was a lot of fun.


And great to finally introduce Tyler to MESBG



Tuesday, 4 August 2026

Battle Record - Middle Earth - The Deeping Wall #MESBG 04/08/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing MESBG again. We'd set up the board for the Shed of the Year pictures, so it would be rude not to have a game.


This was the battle of the Deeping Wall scenario. With Orcs coming on from each end and some engineers trying to get to the wall to blow it up.


I'm not sure if Otty had played this before but it soon became apparent there were some gameplay issues with the width of the battlements.


For the most part you could have two abreast, but some areas where staircases were it was an absolute bottle neck.


Which meant Pikes were literally doubly useful. But even so it led to a lot of congestion on the wall with very few Rohirrim holding off the press of orcs.


This allowed the archers to concentrate fire on the Engineers.


And eventually Legolas started to take toll for their attempts to blow up the wall.


As the Engineers got closer we started to lose the Berserkers holding the flaming brands.


You can see just how spread out the Rohan forces are on the wall, holding back the Orcs at each end,


More shots at the Engineers


Every model that died could come on from the ladders. 


Although there were some breakthrough's onto the battlements, they were often beaten back.


As the Engineers reached the foot of the wall we realised the drainage gate was in the wrong place for the mission. And the Engineers realised they'd lost all the Berserkers to light the explosives.


The battle atop the wall continued. 


But we still couldn't breach the line either end.


Archers continued to shoot at the Engineers, with only reinforcements on the ladders obscuring these vital targets. Each engineer needed to make a moral check and then it was something like a 5 or 6 to blow up the charge to win.


But I think Otty managed to achieve his objective and win the game.


We played on a bit after the game had finished and the Engineers finally found a spark to blow up the wall, but too little too late


Even box cars felt like a cruel jest that it had came after the game had been called.


Lessons learned, but it looks awesome.



I think some additional wooden walkways might be added eventually. I don't know if they'll be detachable though - so we don't end up tipping the advantage the other way round. But a full day of gaming with these guys - WOOT!