Showing posts with label middle earth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label middle earth. Show all posts

Thursday, 15 October 2026

Battle Record - Middle Earth Hill Tribes Vs Rohan #MESBG 15/10/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing MESBG


We were continuing with the War of the Rohirrim scenarios. This one being where Hera is fighting Shan and Wrot while a snow troll gets involved and Helm Hammerhand saves the day. Ben had played it with Otty and said it was quick with the intention we would finish it before Liam turned up. But in the end we'd only just set up when he arrived so Liam and I got to give it a go.


Hera starts in the middle of the board with Shank and Wrot with the snow troll at the far left and Helm far right. Liam, had moved Hera to join Helm and as I hadn't realy understood the scenario hadn't put the orcs in the way to stop her so I didn't bother. 


What followed was some careful measuring depending on who had priority and Helm attacked. But Shank had an ability to make the troll charge while being fearless. Avoiding Helm's terror he was trapped, but he won the duel roll off.


And one-punched the troll. Each wound doing double damage! Shank and Wrot had some weirdly good rolls but not enough to do any damage whatsoever and then Wrot was KO'd


Which left shank to be double teamed by Helm and Hera with the game over, quick smart.


We then decided to revisit last week's sceario, where Hera [in her bridal gear] rides forth to battle Wulf. Otty had played it a couple of times since so it was a chance to try new tactics and not just treat each scenario as 'one and done'!


Hera and Wulf start the battle in the top middle. This time the Hillmen formed a line in the middle with most of the archers on the siege tower. While the Rohirrim formed up with spears in the front rank toward the middle and then every rider has a bow so they were aligned diagonally for over the shoulder shots.


Hera got surrounded and after a poor duel roll spent 2 Might to break even with Wulf, but lost the 50:50 and was cut down. Meanwhile the Rohirrim peppered any archer they could see I think we took down 4 or 5 hillmen in that first turn


In return the Rohan captain was unhorsed and Frealaf rode behind his men to avoid being sniped. Another round of Rohan shooting took a Hillman chief down on the siege tower, with just three hillman warriors charging to face Olwyn. However, with the camp left undefended a sizeable force were attempting to come in at our flank.


This was turn 4 and we'd started to send some of our force forward using the increased strength of the throwing spears. But that was hampered by the reduced hits by moving and shooting. However, the Hillman archers faired much worse. Choosing to target heroes rather than the nearest rider there were multiple 'in the way rolls', coupled with 'horse or rider' rolls, inevitably when it came to the wound roll the 6 required to kill a warrior or 5 to kill the horse either never came or the 5 appeared when the rider was hit! 


Otty had convinced Ben to withdraw his forces, hoping to lure is into the killzone. Instead we wheeled to our right and went for the smaller force in the camp. Some failed terror tests didn't help but we had enough to do damage. 2 out of the 3 hillmen on the siege ramp got into combat with Olwyn 


But the one out of combat got put down to archery fire. We continued to press into the camp although I'm not sure if we charged at this point or were charged. It might have been a turn of weathering the storm


We had new hillmen running up the siege ramp, but the main force had made their move - Wulf and Targ seeking to heroic combat off that loan cavalry. But the on foot Rohan captain also chose to Heroic combat out of the 4 hillmen that had doubled up in charging our front row of cavalry in the middle. We won the 50:50 so would get to go first, with Frealaf, who also broke free.


And despite Liam's reservations [he thought Targ was the better target for Frealaf] we gambled and trapped Wulf. Having already called a Heroic combat - if we got enough bodies on him he wouldn't be able to do springboard off the combat with his Heroic. We'd nullify it. We both got the 6 required and with our fight values the same it was down to another 50:50. Despite some turns were I was accurately predicting every dice roll I'd make this 50:50 would decide the game. 1-3 Wulf wins and kills Frealaf, 5-6 Frealaf and the rider get 10 hits on Wulf.


We win the 50:50.


5's to wound and Wulf is chopped to bits.


I think at this stage the hillmen were broken, but it was after midnight and we called it a night. I'm not sure what the score was at this stage. Both Hera and Wulf were dead, 2 points each. We'd killed a chief for a point and currently no one had left by the siege tower, but technically the hillmen controlled the camp for a point. So it might 3:3 at this stage, but I think the momentum had swung our way and we were well positioned to capitalise on Wulf's demise. We may finish it off next time...


It felt like a very different game this time around. A lot of fun again. The hillmen archers were woeful and it was a huge contrast with our complete reluctance to do 'in the way' rolls whereas the hillmen somehow sacrificed all their high rolls to not be in the way to only get low numbers for wounding. it almost became a joke. I think all they did was kill the Rohan Captains horse, kill one or two riders and perhaps put a wound or two on Olwyn who 'fated' them.


A good game, but the guys are working next Thursday and I can't go the week after so not sure when we'll get together again... 🥺 


Thursday, 8 October 2026

Battle Record - Middle Earth Hill Tribes Vs Rohan #MESBG 08/10/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing MESBG and it was great for us all to be there together again.


We were continuing with the War of the Rohirrim scenarios. This one being the end where Hera [in her bridal gear] rides forth to battle Wulf.


Hera and Wulf start the battle in the top right. All the Hillmen are congregated around the siege tower ramp, with Olwyn at the top of it stopping those already on the ramp. Meanwhile Frealaf and the riders of Rohan come in from the bottom. The Hillmen score a point each by killing Frealaf, a Rohan Captain, getting 3 Hillmen off the end of the siege ramp, having more warriors in the bottom right quadrant and 2 points for killing Hera. Rohan score one point each for killing General Targ, a Hillman Captain, stopping any Hillmen from escaping the siege ramp and having more Rohirrim in the bottom right camp. There is also 2 points for killing Wulf. I was with Otty who was already doom-mongering because there were 20 Hillman Archers and Hera was only able to get an 'in the way' by hiding next to a rocky step in the hill. We're also having to cope with a lot of terror-inducing flaming brands.


But, once again my dice were on fire 🎲🔥 We managed to make a lot of charges and if we won the duel there were often 2 cavalry against one Hillman - 4 wound rolls and only needing a 4 on the dice to kill. So a lot of Hillman fell under the hooves. In return if a Hillman won they also were sometimes killing on 4's - +1 for hatred of Rohan and there were a lot of 2-handed weapons for another +1.


Having won the priority on a few turns General Targ was able to call a heroic move to blunt the cavalry and hold us back. Olwyn had done work on the ramp, killing 2 Hillmen, and about to take out 2 more. A Rohan Captain had joined Hera but was getting bogged down by numbers.


The dice continued to work in our favour. Even if it was just a lot of 4's rolled that always seemed to be just enough to win a duel or take priority. It was almost comical. We went from believing the game was a foregone conclusion before we tarted to utterly dominating.


By about 10:30 Liam and Ben were ready for going home.


Their dice were just so poor. They'd gone from swapping them at ever opportunity to even considering using our Rohan dice! 🤣 This was the Hillman chief's morale check as they were broken, and he fled the board! Ben had even shot into combat, wounded General Targ and killed an archer on the ramp! But then Olwyn fell and the ramp was clear, except for the NPC crone.


But we played on and with the Hillmen heading for the end of the ramp we used our own bows to stop all but one of them, but that was enough, they needed 3 to exit. But elsewhere there was some success and Hera, Frealaf and the Rohan Captain all fell with just Wulf and Targ the only heroes left.


My dice continued to swing wildly - a mix of success and failure.


We tried to get to Wulf and hold the village quadrant.


Targ was still a threat but his sole wound was his downfall. Having been hit by friendly fire he succumbed and we surrounded Wulf bu were beaten back.


More units abandoned the field.


and we reformed the line to take down Wulf and the last Hillman archer.


We surrounded them


Absolute scenes as Wulf rolls his 3D6 duel dice!


Taking the field completely with a final score of 6:4 to Rohan


This was the dead pile.


And those who's luck just wouldn't rise to the occasion.


A really good game but so much was dictated by dice rolls that they just couldn't reconcile in the end. If they'd got the Hillmen off the ramp that would have been 5:5, but that failed morale check by the chief and getting shot on the ramp lost them the game.



Thursday, 1 October 2026

Battle Record - Middle Earth Hill Tribes and Harad Vs Rohan #MESBG 01/10/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community after a week away from the shed I'm back, but it's just Otty and I. Ben was on shifts and Liam has been back in hospital again [get well soon bud], but hopefully he'll out next week. So it was just the 'elite' of the hobby shed crew 😎 We spent an hour just chatting, Otty has quite the stressful job and was somewhat apologetic about having to vent. But he created this space for us, to reset and support our mental health. I'd have spent the entire evening just chatting if he needed it. Gaming is just an excuse to gather, it's really just about spending time together.


But we did have a game in the end. One of the War of the Rohirrim scenarios where a Mumak smashes into Edoras trying to destroy the city. The Rohirrim stand in the centre and I've got 36 Hill Tribesman, Wulf, General Targ, Tribe captain and Harad chief on the Mumak. Having faced one at Warhammer World I wanted to see what it was like to play. 


While I was getting it to the middle of the board I went aggressive with Wulf. I pushed deep, heroic combatted a spearman to get to Otty's Leader, who did Heroic Strike, won the duel with ease and cut Wulf's horse out from underneath him. I was careful not to get in with Hera behind as well.


I lost priority, but the Harad chief heroic moved the Mumak in the centre [not it is pointing the wrong direction because the trunk and tusks make it almost impossible to play. It just trampled through more than half of the Rohan force, squishing everything to paste. I think it ended in combat at Otty's hero managed to put two wounds on it as he has Hatred: Mumak and Mumakbane for this mission. It passed the courage test so it didn't go bereserk.



Next round and the Mumak still facing the wrong direction trampled further, killed a few of my men but failed to kill Otty's leader [Haleth or Hama I forget which]. So stuck in combat, which stops the rest of my guys being squished, who then bundle into [let's say] Haleth and Hera who was attacked by General Targ who cut her down.


With the final turn I tabled Otty. If I recall Haleth was killed not by the Mumak, but by a lowly spear support filthy tribesman! For me the forces were ridiculously unbalanced. But Otty said if the Mumak gets wounded and fails its courage the opposing player can move it and that can make all the difference. 


Once again Otty had some shockingly bad dice but that initial trample did so much damage, prevented his own Heroic move and completely shifted the game balance. I'm not sure he's going to want to play that scenario again, but it was entertaining if a little saddening how one-sided it became.


Meanwhile, Shed 1.0 is properly becoming an organised workspace for his hobby projects. He used part of the Shed of the Year prize money to get an FDM printer, you can just see 2 out of 3 ruined Rohan houses at the bottom of the image. So there will be a lot of exciting new things coming to the shed.





Thursday, 17 September 2026

Battle Record - Middle Earth Orc Scouts Vs Eagles and Dwarves #MESBG 17/09/26

Afternoon #Warhammer Community we've been playing MESBG again. We're hoping to go to a doubles tournament at Warhammer World next year so we decided to try out some lists and what it's like to pair up. Otty and I had a load of Orc Scouts [I think] while Ben and Liam had a mix of Eagles, Beorn and Dain Ironfoot on a Boar, with three mountain goat riders and a load of dwarves. 


The mission was a weird one where both players in each team secretly chose a character to kill but if you got your targeted character to within the central objective you scored additional points. Otty already predicted it would not end well for us as Dain and Beorn are practically unstoppable.


But, it was night fighting and that meant our archers were getting +1 to wound. Which meant my initial setup on the cliff ruin took out Liam's 2 crossbow dwarves. Which seemed like a bit of an alpha strike at the time. Otty did a lot of the movement and there was some lively debate about where he'd put them, versus what the intention was.


But I think we started to lose priority and heroics weren't going our way. 50:50s either went almost exclusively to us or to Ben and Liam, I forget which but again there was a lot of debate about it.


I think we started to do some damage, but it was too spread around. Dain's Boar took a wound. 


Then at some point Dain himself took 3 wounds but he passed all three Fate rolls. We then couldn't get back into combat to do actual damage.


Some impressive dice rolling did not help any of us.


With Orcs dropping all over the place we were losing ground.


Outnumbering the big beasts and trapping them became harder to achieve, with that being our only hope of killing anyone off. 


It was getting late an I think the forces of good had managed to kill most of what they needed while we'd failed to take out Dain or Beorn.


Lots still to learn, definitely the game felt more competitive than usual which meant a lot of quibbling about rules. Not to mention I think we're all going deaf. The amount of times someone says something and then immediately someone else will say the exact some point! I've been doing it for months to much amusement, but we're all doing it now.


We had a lot of fun, but I think we need to prioritise smoother gameplay over accuracy. Whenever we go to Warhammer World that's usually how we play. Even if we think there is a rules contention you compromise because you don't want to be seen as 'that guy'. Quibbling over things just breaks the flow of the game. We'll get there.