I wonder if my efforts are better spent elsewhere? The pictures were much better than usual though this time so even if folk don't read everything there's plenty to look at. Bottom line is if I'm ultimately doing this as a record of my games is it worth it? And if anyone else reads them that's just a bonus...
But that's just an observation post Thrones, I know it appears a little down but the actual event was great and the weekend away was so much fun. Not having been for two years, when Escalation had only just been introduced it was interesting to see how to open army choices faired and it did raise the issue of 'best game votes' in potentially a more favorable light. It was clear from Scott winning that his 4 favourite game votes were the deciding factor, this fits with the organisers view that it's not the winning that's important. Now I know this arbitrary measure is an issue with some people but I actually think it works now. When you open up the amry choices to abuse, with all kinds of beardy, spamalot, cheese-fests then win at all costs becomes inevitable. BUt if it's at the cost of someone having a rubbish game, then how do you prevent that?
Well if you're going to slaughter everyone you face then you have to find a way to do it with a smile and personality that will win over your victim. Alternatively you can bring a sensible list win some games but also behave in a way that's going to win friends. Now I only got the one best game vote and from experience I can see that that's often your last game, it's the most fresh in your mind things are usually relaxed and the event is winding down. I understand how Scott got four, he's sucvh a fun guy to hang with but it can be a fickle decision so on the one hand it's something definitely out of your control, I mean I'm a nice guy, people like my army, I have fun when I game and play cinematically above competitively. I bring sweets and free wound markers, they're marketing tools as well as bribes ;) but that's no guarantee either way But it's definitely a tournament leveller, it means those WAAC lists don't dominate.
So however frustrating it can be, and I've looking at the score sheet and how I faired over the weekend against Scott with the scouts from my third game. He scored 233 Carnage points and 49 VPs over the weekend. In comparison I did 215 and 42 VPs. Our positions were vastly different though as I got a favourite game vote meaning I finished 61st and he finished 96th. Game wise though his force was more successful. That obviously doesn;t sound right but I guess it's not how you win but how you play that counts. Incidentally that's why they no longer have a list of Best Army and Favorite Player plaques in Bugman's, because it's not about winning.
So although I get why this mechanic has issues I think on balance it's probably for the best. You can't have total freedom in army choice without something to balance it out. As for the rest of the event I was a little disappointed about the limitations for display of best army, I hope that's just a temporary thing. I;ve seen more nominations in recent events so three seemed a little harsh. I definitely thought Liam deserved a shot, every time he;s been he's taken a different army painted, converted and scratchbuilt in places to amazing standards. Honorable mention is nice but I thought it deserved more.
Given the new shops I was actually surprsed the venue still felt so big, there's far more room than I gave it credit for, which was a relief.
My only other issues - the food wasn't quite as good as previous years. It all looked freshly prepared on site, I had a burger and I'm sure it was 'scratchbuilt' but the actual patty wasn't great. Unfortunately the other options didn't appeal to my delicate stomach. I'm sure a lot of efffort was put in it just wasn't up to the standard of previous trips.
We were also a little disappointed to discover that the exhibition is not included in your ticket price. Now folk said the £7.50 was worth it but given the only free time to look at it was after the event there was no way I was going to fork out for it and have to rush through. I'm sure pictures don't do it justice but having not experienced it in the flesh I honestly can say the pictures work fine for me right now.
However, this Age of Sigmar table was awesome and goes some way to get an additional hobby fix without going to the exhibition, rushing round and failing to get my money's worth
I loved this table, the colours and the extra details made it really good. I was little disappointed about the early closing though. I'm surprised they shut at 8, although Wednesday it's 9 and the remainder of the week its 6pm! I think they're missing a trick but then they know they're customers/business model.
All that said we came away with renewed faith in the events held there. The events team put in a lot of effort and despite the time since our last visit they were extremely helpful, supportive and friendly. I even got name checked during the awards ceremony thanks to my repeated failing in being able to do simple mathematics on my scroing sheets.
Not to mention the playful banter the staff had at my expense for my army lists that had hole punches a few millimetres offset from their intended positions. I can't thank them enough for their patience and hospitality, they make the evnt special, of course so did the beer and the company of my gaming buddies too.
It was a great weekend and we'll be back again
What I try do is tell the battle report like a small story Dave & if there's a lot of pictures of the game just add them below, but the think is I didn't know if people like that way better then the older way tbh.ReplyDelete
Apologies in advance for what I'm sure will be a wall of text.ReplyDelete
I got to a point where I wondered why I wrote up all my battles. I had feedback from people telling me that was one of the things they enjoyed on the blog but it got to a point where I was putting a couple of hours into a battle report. All of that adds up and FtF is probably testament to why my armies aren't painted! It's great to have a record of the battles but it's rare that I actually look back. I've now toned down the number of reports I do and I'm getting more painting done. I do sometimes lament how much painting I might've done had I not blogged so much.
I've made no secret of my opinions of favourite game votes. At the GW Doubles I've been on the receiving end of both sides of them. We took first place on favourite game votes and lost first place through lack of them.
My main issue is that they don't actually reflect how nice you were to play against. They're far too random. Do you vote for the game that was the most fun? The player that was nicest (or gave you sweets)? The narrowest loss? You might lose your game to a really nice pair of guys but your favourite game is the one where you crushed a pair of ass-hats. Do they actually check who you vote for now? Could you go with friends and just vote for each other even if you didn't actually play?
The big issue though is that it feels lazy. As someone who has put a huge amount of time into developing a tournament system that rewards friendly play without soft scoring, I know it's not easy to do. Favourite game votes feel like GW's way of saying "you sort yourselves out, we don't really care".
I was initially against the no holds barred list building but I actually think you have to let people self moderate to a point. Question is, if you don't want WAAC-type attitude then why keep score at all? Why reward winning? Ultimately it's a tournament not a club night. I think it's just as disheartening for players to perform well and not see their placing reflect it as it is to be crushed by a power gamer.
Trouble is, GW's events have been some of the best I've ever attended. I can't help but feel it's in spite of the events team rather than because of them though. They seem to be putting more thought into things but I really struggle to justify the expense. Sadly the independent scene feels like it's in decline so they'll get the numbers. There's no competition so no really push to do better.
The painting competition is a good example of this. Liam's output is amazing. The speed at which he churns out stunning armies is frankly depressing to someone like me! I haven't even painted the grotesques he made for me!
On the subject of the exhibition. I totally think it's worth the £7.50 at least once. Definitely don't rush around though as there's lots of little details to spot that you don't see in pictures. Photos really don't do it justice. I was totally skeptical but glad I took the plunge.
Anyway, I'll wrap it up by saying that the first time we went to the doubles there were 130 teams. Last time I think there were 30 or so. Whilst there's been a decline in the hobby I don't think it's that sharp
Holy crap that was a lot of text. Basically a blog post right there and no painting done again tonight!ReplyDelete
I am a big fan of writing up battle reports for my blog, but I do agree with you, it takes a lot of time and effort to do.ReplyDelete
I think it has a lot to do with the fact that I enjoy the gaming side of the hobby more. I love using a fully painted army and make every effort to get my armies finished, but I would describe my painting skills for some armies as decent tabletop ranging to very good tabletop for others. I'm never going to win any painting competitions, but like showing off my armies in battle reports.
I like reading some battle reports to see the different perspectives on game play and army style, but some of them are a slog to get through (I know that is rich coming from me, I think my battle reports are some of the longest around the web.
Even if you decide to no longer write them up as battle reports, the pictures are still a welcome addition to the blog and its always nice to see the figures used for one of their intended purposes.
I like battle reports. Always have, always will.ReplyDelete
I also like the Warhammer world events, look forward to them every time. Not really fussed about the best game votes personally. I'm never going to win or be in the position where they would make a difference to me. But I think the atmosphere of the events is great and I always leave full of inspiration for new armies. Same with the exhibition which is just amazing, and well worth the money in my opinion.
Anyway keep up the good work. And cheers for talking the time to post.